Original Brooklyn Pizza Incorporated in Commack

Great food. Nice owner.

There are good places, and there are places that are good - and make you feel like family. The guys at Brooklyn are just that - they’ll fix up however you want it, they’ll do something just the way you ask, and all while making some small talk and offering up some sample of Italian bread. This place was adjacent to my office for a little over a year, and I must’ve went 100 times or more, love it.

The pizza is very good you want real good ny pizza this is the spot cheese is A+ crust is A+

My family came to visit from Florida over the weekend. I ordered a couple of pies & some garlic knots for dinner. It was a pretty penny.. but i heard that this place “was the bomb” and their food was great. I saw a few bad reviews, i figured i’d still give this place a try. My family had arrived, and so did the delivery driver. Super fast delivery! The driver was so nice, and polite. Once we sat down to eat, my sister pointed out there was a hair in one of the pies. The garlic knots where like rubber... I tried to call the restaurant but i was hung up on. Super disappointed!

Very good pizza nice and fresh.

Original Brooklyn never disappoints! It is an absolute staple in my household (especially their chicken marsala pizza). We've ordered personally and in large quantities for parties and we've been completely satisfied every time, right down to delivery being perfectly on time.

The fresh mozzarella pizza is excellent. They also have the best--best grandma pizza. The rice balls taste like those in Italy. Nice, friendly service. Excellent delivery times.

This place is great! Good pricing, large portions and the staff are always helpful.

Food is always delicious & it has been for many years.

Best family own pizza.

Regular Cheese pie tasted like it had synthetic cheese blend, not good. Wont be going back. And on top of the bad pizza I get hit with extra 1.56 for using debit card...total turn off. With the many pizza choices there are in commack not a good pizza move.

Hands down my favorite pizza on Long Island. It's as close to Brooklyn as you can get... with a paper thin, crispy crust and the perfect mix of cheese and sauce, Original Brooklyn is my go-to Pizza spot. Highly Recommended!!

The everything pizza is the best around, I never had that style from this place, they did a wonderful job,! I loved it

Hands down best cheese pie on long island

Outstanding rice balls and specialty pizza.

When I think of pizza this place is the standard. I grew up going to this place, and can’t recommend it strongly enough. I moved away and can’t find anything like it nearby. Crust, sauce, cheese amazing. Linguini pasta primavera is insane. Great owners who know your name. Great neighborhood staple. Thank you for all you do.

Nice place, nice people, good food

This place has the BEST cauliflower crust pizza!!! OMG it is to die for!!! If you haven’t tried it yet, you owe yourself to do so!!! Amazing thin crust!!!

Excellent pizza. Excellent service.

Delicious east coast pie!!

This site is my preferable restaurant. Of all restaurants I know I love it most. I always suggests to my friends to go to visit this place. when I I need a proper lunchon, this place comes instantly to my head. superb and all kinds of food and a rich menu.courteous staff members, and pleasant vibes. Also important, the tariff is honest. I sent my friends to this restaurant with no doubt.

Not the best. Very expensive for mediocre food. Eggplant rollatini was terrible. They put all the spaghetti right on top of it what a disaster . Last resort.

Try the rice balls absolutely delicious